Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-223.27.94.3-20130830163221/@comment-5872914-20131201174634

Nechigawara wrote: Because those studio rarely did romantic Comedy anime. I think this sentence is very clearly. I don't want to see Hayate becoming Fate/Zero or Code Geass alike. They didn't match with this genre of story. Unlike Manglobe, J.C., A1 who familar with love comedy.

Like I said before. Romantic Comedy don't need remake. Retell story is not good for this genre. It's will make people bored like J.C. did with SS2.

About the selling, this is not kind of anime that will get high selling. Hayate now totally out of trend about the anime. Not so much service, not ecchi, etc. Also most of otaku always change their interest to the new anime. Only left is a fan like me anf Hinasama. And Hayate doesn't has a large fanbase. (See the number of this wikia member, low piority of the scanlation, less event in Japan, bla bla bla)

PS. Rememerber that Hayate no Gotoku! is Romantic Comedy and Parody Story. Beside now there are meny serious point. Hata-sama still include the joke and parody along with a love story.

Edit:: Just see your new opinion. If you don't care about Hayate is a love-com. Please go away. This is why Hayate is Hayate. Are you referring to the animation quality? If not, then it seems pointless. Also to mention, Hata originally chose a combination of romance, comedy, parody and action (though the last part got downplayed to the point of being borderline non-existent). Also to mention, he designed it as more of a parody series (the love-com part is secondary). Maybe if he started to make it more serious towards the end (put more action and adventure in it, like what Negima did, starting out as something similar to this and becoming darker in content as it progresses to the point that the romcom part is secondary) and less otaku-ish (due to what you mentioned about thay they change their interest when new stuff premieres), stop making it feel slow due to its borderline slice-of-life nature, and possibly make a sequel (Negima got one, albeit stealthily, in the form of UQ Hodler), then maybe it would become something similar to Borderlands (action-adventure series with lots of shoutouts and comedic tones). That would increase sales and start up a new fanbase. Also to mention, Bones (which you mentioned) is making Space Dandy, which is a full-on comedy series and has bunch of shoutouts like this, and is directed by Shinichiro Watanabe of Cowboy Bebop and Samurai Champloo fame.

BTW, Code geass was animated by Sunrise (which I didn't mention)

On another note, A1 Pictures does anime for Aniplex only since they're owned by them (Hayate is released by Geneon).